Saturday, January 21, 2012

A Review of *Out of the Silent Planet*...

...which I read in a matter of two days, and it only took me that long because of inevitable interruption. I hardly believe in moderation in the course of reading. I flirted with the idea of telling you the entire story earlier today (why I picked the book up, why I had to stop reading at 2:00 in the afternoon, etc.), but you will have to content yourself with only a brief review. This review is adapted from one that was published on GoodReads only moments before:

Out of the Silent Planet (Space Trilogy, #1)Out of the Silent Planet by C.S. Lewis
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

First I realized that I never could have read this book when I was any  younger. I lacked the patience, and could never have converted Lewis's descriptions into visualizations of thought. I was a great lover of dialogue in those days, and could not tolerate long expanses of description. It is a wonder I ever got through *Parelandra,* and no wonder I gained little from the experience.

This is a work of science fiction--and all that description implies. It is also a bit of a theological fancy. Makes for a great story of course.

Lewis envisions a society totally unlike ours, but similar to what ours might have been like, and then introduces elements of our own society as distorted by the fall of mankind, introduces them as a stranger would, in fact. You must, of course, read the book to find out what happens in consequence.

This book was of course wonderful, and I certainly suggest you read it.. I don't love it like I love *That Hideous Strength,* the third and final volume in the series, but still I say that it was very good. I like the way Lewis reveals himself as... at the end. I shall not say, for it might just spoil the book.

No really, the Lewis bit is only incidental to the rest of the narrative, but I like it. And it ties the book in more clearly with the first chapter of *Perelandra,* which has long been my favorite chapter of that particular book. Oh, yes, I love, love, love that first chapter. I have even quoted it from time to time.

I look forward to reading the whole book [*Perelandra*]in full again now that I am old enough to appreciate it as I never could have in my youth. I'm reminded of the inscription at the beginning of *The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe,* which I first read when I was very young...and needs must quote here at some much later date.

View all my reviews

4 comments:

Jim said...

I loved the first chapter of Parelandra, too, but I didn't much care for That Hideous Strength. Is there an upcoming post on that one? If so, I'll wait. If not, let me go ahead and ask--why did you like THS so much?

Jim said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
kf.ruhamah said...

It isn't much of a review really. What do I like about *That Hideous Strength?* I don't know, but its among my favorite books. I like the fact that the characters are a bunch of ambitious intellectuals, the surrealism of the scene where Mark starts noticing the paintings on the walls, the mythical enactment at the end that reminds me now of Chesterton's *The Man Who Was Thursday.* If you don't like THS, I wonder what you would make (or have made, if you've read it) of TMWWT.

Review forthcoming? I guess I'd have to go ahead and read it again first. Any excuse, you know.

kf.ruhamah said...

Jim, I think one of the reason's I like *That Hideous Strength* so much is because I read *A Wrinkle in Time* when I was very young. I think I recall some similarities.

I started Perelandra last night.